Skip to main content

What To Do With All Those Deer

What To Do With All Those Deer

Findings from the latest research on deer population control are out and surprise of surprises, immunocontraception (birth control) still doesn't work.

It's a shame really that so much money and effort is expended on a problem that already has a solution. I've worked on several deer population control efforts and reviewed piles more. In nearly every instance, the parties involved had to go through every step of the process, ignoring the recommendations of wildlife managers and the past experience of others, exhausting all other possibilities before inevitably ending up with the same conclusion.


What We've Learned
Human populations keep sprawling across the landscape and deer populations continue growing in range and number--eventually they collide. Finding ways to control deer numbers, in turn, becomes a daunting task for state wildlife agencies.


The first option usually championed by the non-hunting public is non-lethal means. One technique is trap and transfer, which is extremely expensive and rarely successful. The most recent figures I could obtain put the cost at between $2,000 and $3,000 per animal.

Someone has to foot that bill, and most of the time it's the taxpayers. With ever-escalating tax rates, it's hard to justify spending money on something citizens (hunters) are willing to do for free, and in some cases even pay to do.


Furthermore, it doesn't really work. Research has shown that some animals perish during the process from stress or physical injuries. Still more succumb to stress after being released. And many of the remaining survivors later perish as a direct result of being transferred to a new/foreign environment.


Even if they could survive at a higher rate, where would you put them? Most adjacent or nearby areas have similar problems. With recent proliferation of maladies like CWD and EHD, transporting is ill-advised, and may be illegal.

The other non-lethal means is immunocontraception. The most common contraceptive drugs available require two treatments the first year, followed by an annual booster--for every breeding female in the population. Some treated does may continue to cycle as many as five times. Drugs used to date have moderate to high failure rates, and their use is permitted by the FDA only on an experimental basis and only under tightly controlled circumstances. Additionally, you must prevent all untreated deer from entering the area, or all your efforts are for naught.

That brings us to lethal solutions. The one so often considered first by non-hunters is sharpshooters or culling. This is an effective short-term means of reducing deer numbers. Like transport however, it's very expensive. It's also an irresponsible use of taxpayer's money and a reprehensible abuse of the public trust (deer are public property and therefore owned by the citizens). How is it that those states can deny the public access to a renewable, harvestable, public resource, and a revenue-generating recreational opportunity and then tax them to pay a professional "hit man?"

That brings us to the other lethal method of deer control. This one has been proven over and over to be the most effective, cost-effective, efficient, fair and equitable means of controlling exurban (urban or suburban) deer populations over both the short and long terms. It's bowhunting.

Application
Many of you are probably thinking, "that's all well and good, but how does knowing all this help me to be a more successful hunter?" Consider the equation: success = preparation + opportunity. Too many deer is not a problem; it's an opportunity. Archery hunters are the solution. The difficulty becomes selling yourself, which is made easier through organization and education.

Odds are fairly long for an individual hunter approaching a landowner and asking permission to hunt, particularly in an exurban area. However, the response is often different to an organized group of archery hunters, particularly if the group comes with credentials.

There are numerous ways to approach this. In Maine, for instance, the Maine Bowhunters Association developed a Bowhunters and Landowners Information Program (BLIP). It's applicable statewide, operated in conjunction with the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife and requires hunters to meet certain prerequisite conditions, including having passed an archery hunter education course. Having the state's blessing and being able to show proficiency and responsibility puts landowners more at ease.

Local bowhunting co-ops are also springing up in exurban areas. They recruit members who can demonstrate experience and responsibility. They then match them with property owners. Most provide their services for free, and many carry insurance that removes any liability from the property owner.

The other key to opening doors is educating the non-hunting public. The information provided above is a good start. Some more helpful resources are listed at the end of this column.

Provide this to individual landowners, communities, schools and local law enforcement agencies (the guys who get called out to car-deer collisions).

This type of hunting is not for everyone. You'll be in and around developed areas, and will likely have more restrictions and conditions placed on you. It also takes more effort. Going the extra mile in demonstrating your willingness to respect exurban landowners could get you into areas where little or no hunting occurs otherwise, and where downtown deer grow old and large.

Additional Resources:Guide to Urban Bowhunting: The Guide for Addressing urban Deer Problems with the Use of Responsible Bowhunting. The National Bowhunter Education Foundation.

An Evaluation of Deer Management Options. New Hampshire Fish and Game Department Publication No. DR-11.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

New for 2021: Elite Archery Bows, Slick Trick Broadheads and CBE Sight

New for 2021: Elite Archery Bows, Slick Trick Broadheads and CBE Sight

Learn more about two new Elite Archery bows, the Enkore and Remedy, two new broadhead from Slick Trick and a new site from Custom Bow Equipment (CBE).

New for 2021: Hoyt RX-5, RX-5 Ultra, Ventum 30 and Ventum 33

New for 2021: Hoyt RX-5, RX-5 Ultra, Ventum 30 and Ventum 33

ATA 2021 NeDuring this video from the Archery Trade Association's New Product Premiere showcase, Bowhunter's TV Mike Carney visited with Evan Williams, pro staff manager for Hoyt Archery, to learn about the new RX-5, RX-5 Ultra, Ventum and Ventum 33 bows.w Product - Hoyt

New for 2021: Excalibur Crossbow, BowTech Bows, TightSpot Quiver, Ripcord Rests, Black Gold Sights

New for 2021: Excalibur Crossbow, BowTech Bows, TightSpot Quiver, Ripcord Rests, Black Gold Sights

New for 2021 are several hunter-defined products, such as the Excalibur TwinStrike Crossbow, BowTech Solution and Solution SS Bows, TightSpot Pivot 2.5 Quiver, Ripcord Cage and Code Red X arrowrests, and Black Gold Pro FX and Pro Hunter HD sights.

New for 2021: Rage Broadhead, Nockturnal Nock, Carbon Express Arrows

New for 2021: Rage Broadhead, Nockturnal Nock, Carbon Express Arrows

New for 2021, here's a look at the new Rage Trypan NC, Nockturnal Shift Nock, Carbon Express Maxima RED Contour and D-Stroyer PileDRIVER arrows.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

Crunching the numbers on North America's most important game species2020 State of the Whitetail Report Whitetail

2020 State of the Whitetail Report

Jason Snavely - June 29, 2020

Crunching the numbers on North America's most important game species

Craft your shafts for maximum performance in the field.How to Build the Best Hunting Arrow Arrows & Broadheads

How to Build the Best Hunting Arrow

Jon E. Silks

Craft your shafts for maximum performance in the field.

With a pull of the trigger, the R18's limbs will expand vertically thanks to the VertiCoil Cam System.New Ravin R18 Turns the Crossbow World Inside Out ATA Show

New Ravin R18 Turns the Crossbow World Inside Out

Mark Demko - January 20, 2021

With a pull of the trigger, the R18's limbs will expand vertically thanks to the VertiCoil Cam...

You know the Spicy Elk Venison Vindaloo Recipe Recipes

Spicy Elk Venison Vindaloo Recipe

Jenny Nguyen-Wheatley

You know the "Indian food is so spicy!" exclamations you often get from people? Well, this...

See More Trending Articles

More Whitetail

These are the archery shots you should and shouldn't take on whitetails. Where to Shoot a Deer: Bowhunting Shot Placement How-To

Where to Shoot a Deer: Bowhunting Shot Placement

Christian Berg

These are the archery shots you should and shouldn't take on whitetails.

The best place to start hunting a buck is where you found his sheds earlier in the year.The Secrets Shed Antlers Tell About Whitetails Whitetail

The Secrets Shed Antlers Tell About Whitetails

Bill Winke

The best place to start hunting a buck is where you found his sheds earlier in the year.

These recent findings can help you better manage your buck population.New Deer Management Study: Small-Antlered Bucks & Stump Sprouts Whitetail

New Deer Management Study: Small-Antlered Bucks & Stump Sprouts

Jason Snavely - August 10, 2020

These recent findings can help you better manage your buck population.

Crunching the numbers on North America's most important game species2020 State of the Whitetail Report Whitetail

2020 State of the Whitetail Report

Jason Snavely - June 29, 2020

Crunching the numbers on North America's most important game species

See More Whitetail

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE Arrow

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Petersen's Bowhunting App

Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Petersen's Bowhunting subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now