Unique Tactics for Rattling and Decoying

Unique Tactics for Rattling and Decoying

Bill Pellegrino took the antlers off this full-mount decoy to lure his buck into bow range.

I carry a unique set of rattling antlers that always seems to draw a little harassment from my hunting buddies -- until they try them. I use a heavy, 5-point whitetail antler along with a stubby, 3-point elk antler. I like the combination because I can really make a ton of noise when I want to. Being able to project the sound of battle into far-reaching places has worked well for me in the past, and it did again on this trip. Bill poked some fun at me when he first saw the odd-looking pair, but after watching a buck run toward my position one noisy, windblown afternoon, he was looking to replace his own smallish rattling rack.

Now that I taught Bill a thing or two about rattling, it was his turn to unveil a new, secret weapon. Just prior to leaving for Iowa, Bill's taxidermist completed a full-body doe mount Bill planned to use as a decoy. He then had another friend weld a lightweight frame beneath the decoy so it could be firmly planted in the ground. A spindly pair of detachable antlers was also furnished so the decoy could be used as a doe or a small buck. On the drive to Iowa, we named the decoy Sally, which was shortened to Sal with the antlers installed.

Now, I've seen many mass-produced decoys work fantastically, but this ultra-realistic decoy worked better than any I've ever seen! One afternoon, Bill and I set up on opposite ends of a five-acre alfalfa field. I could see his position from my perch, and I watched him place Sal (antlers installed) approximately 20 yards in front of the giant oak that hosted his treestand. As the evening passed, I observed in amazement as every deer that entered that field marched straight over to investigate Bill's new decoy.

BOWHUNTING Associate Publisher Danny Farris has found lots of success with this unusual set of rattling antlers, which features one whitetail antler and one elk antler. Farris says this allows him to really make a racket and send the sounds of a simulated buck fight a long way -- something that can be particularly helpful on windy days.

Does and bucks alike paraded in front of his stand, and incredibly, none of them spooked. One young buck even approached Sal head-to-head and began licking his antlers! I told Bill having that decoy was like having his own deer magnet. I don't know if the secret is in the realistic-looking eyes or in the decoy being covered with actual deer hair. Whatever it was, it was awesome.

Shortly after arriving home, I took the full-body cape of my Iowa doe to my taxidermist and told him I wanted to have a decoy made. After witnessing Bill's success with his mounted decoy, the cost would be a small sacrifice for such an effective whitetail-hunting weapon.

Later, I discovered Primos Hunting Calls has introduced Harry -- a new, hair-on deer decoy that retails for far less than what I'm paying for a full-body doe mount. Although the decoy doesn't use real deer hair, it certainly looks very realistic. So, anyone who is interested might consider giving the Primos version a try.

Recommended for You

Bow Accessories

6 Ways to Make Your Bow Quieter

Darron McDougal

Is your bow setup a bit noisy? Try these tips to silence it.

Treestands & Blinds

How Do You Get Up the Tree for Saddle Hunting?

Greg Staggs

These tools and tactics are what minimalist tree saddle hunters use to climb!

Big Game

Elk Calling With the Experts

Tracy Breen

Learn how to lure wary bulls into bow range.

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

South African Warthog

Mike Schoby and his wife Dory go on an action-packed South African hunt for plains game including the warthog.

See more Popular Videos

Trending Stories

ATA Show

Best New Bows for 2019

Tony J. Peterson - January 10, 2019

We've rounded up the best new compound bows at the 2019 ATA Show. Here are our top picks for...


Shooting Your Bow With One Eye Versus Two

Bill Winke

Bill Winke explains the benefits of both shooting techniques.

ATA Show

New Mechanical Broadheads for 2019

Brian Strickland - January 10, 2019

Check out our top picks for the best new mechanical broadheads to debut at the 2019 ATA Show!

See More Stories

More Whitetail


How to Shoot Your Biggest Buck Ever

Bill Winke - November 02, 2016

Hunting deer is far from predictable. It is not like baking a pie or programming a computer,


Are Some Bucks Unkillable?

Bill Winke

Bill Winke says don't waste your time hunting these deer.


How to Hunt Open Country Bucks in the Rut

Alex Gyllstrom - November 07, 2017

It's hard to believe it's been almost a decade since I met my buddy Cody. We were hired...

See More Whitetail

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Temporary Price Reduction


Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services


GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.