Most Controversial Bowhunting Innovations of All Time

Most Controversial Bowhunting Innovations of All Time

There's no doubt the cyclical world of bowhunting has seen a whole lot of change over the years. Fred Bear probably wouldn't have had much need for all the gadgets on the shelves nowadays, and his feathered fedora would've seemed weird alongside the studded jeans, black bows and tribal-style tattoos at the 2013 ATA show.

In the burgeoning years of our sport — the first bowhunting season was held in Wisconsin in 1934 — carbon and plastic were used for space shuttles and Tupperware, and the long bow was the only game in town. Then came the recurve, only to be steamrolled years later by Holless Wilber Allen's compound bow, which was approved for patent in 1969.


Most of the early innovations in bowhunting — aluminum arrows, plastic fletchings, stabilizers and the like — were met with excitement, but in an industry that prides itself on a traditionally minimalist approach, there's been a fair share of new introductions that have gotten the shaft...literally.



The rules of fair chase and ethics in bowhunting are frequently up for debate, but there's no doubt that these bowhunting innovations have caused the biggest stir.

Rac-Em-Bac'™s Bow Mag

This is probably the most recent example of a controversial 'œinnovation' in the bowhunting world. I'™d say calling this an innovation might be a stretch, but the Bow Mag by Rac-Em-Bac certainly started a fierce conversation when it was introduced this past January. The manufacturer says this product — which essentially allows you to secure your .38 or .357 Magnum round on the end of your arrow — is 'œperfect for big game and varmits' and that it'™s a 'œrevolutionary new product.' I'™d argue with both. Not only is this pseudo-broadhead illegal for hunting purposes in a lot of states, its Frankenstien-like combination of ammunition and archery creates a slippery slope for hunters everywhere. The Bowhunter editors scoffed at the Bow Mag when it first hit the scene, and we have a feeling readers will have the same reaction.

The Mechanical Broadhead

Some hunters might think the mechanical broadhead is a recent development. Not so fast. The effort to create larger wound channels on game and a more versatile broadhead goes back quite a long way — the argument between fixed blade enthusiasts and new school mechanical users has been around just as long.

Traditional archers maintain that the reliability and precision of a fixed blade provides a truer flight and cut than the mechanicals, which have been known to malfunction or fail to open after deployment. But the wider wound channels and quicker recoveries experienced with modern slip cam broadheads, among others, is starting to turn the tides in recent years. No doubt the innovations will continue to progress with the debate, but we can say for sure that bowhunting has come a long way since Greg Johnson introduced the first Rocket Aeroheads in the late 1980s.

Bow-Mounted Rangefinders

In a sport that'™s preeminently old school, a bow-mounted electronic rangefinder seems pretty futuristic. But in recent years, major players like Leupold have introduced these mounts for a consumer market seemingly happy to accept them. Though the Pope & Young club says that 'œthe use of electronic devices for attracting, locating or pursuing game or guiding the hunter to such game, or by the use of a bow or arrow to which any electronic device is attached' is not fair chase hunting, many still use them where legal. As most would expect, traditional bowhunters remain opposed to using anything battery-powered in the deer woods.

Crossbows and Crossbow Hunting

Crossbows and their use for hunting are by far the most controversial topic in today'™s bowhunting world.

When Arkansas made crossbows legal during bow seasons in 1973 (Wyoming had always allowed crossbows during archery season) the popularity and proliferation of the technology was nowhere near its peak.

But with companies like TenPoint, Barnett and PSE stepping to the forefront to mass-produce them and more states legalizing their use, crossbows slowly became more prevalent. Fast-forward nearly four decades and, according to the ATA, crossbows sales have risen 70 to 80 percent in five years.

The Compound Bow

In the early years of the compound bow and its development--Holless Wilber Allen'™s patent was approved in 1969 after three years of waiting--a quality recurve bow was probably faster than its new counterpart. Allen\'s initial design was basic, but the core idea was revolutionary: use the principles of kinetic energy to design a pully system for a bow that would increase arrow speed. Using mostly wood for his first model, the truss handle was made of pine boards and the limb cores of oak flooring, Allen was able to achieve a significant increase in arrow speed over a recurve bow of equal draw weight. By 1977, there were 100 different models of compound bows available, only 50 recurve models.

But even this revolutionary design had its detractors in the beginning. Traditionalists have always maintained that this complicated cam system has made archery more cumbersome, requiring a bow press to make adjustments to let-off and draw length or even to simply replace a string. While we wouldn\'t even recognize bowhunting today without Allen\'s invention, we can all be sure that the recurve loyalist will always have their say in this debate.

Poison Pod Arrows

Again, this particular product probably doesn\'t fit that well as an innovation, but for some, it\'s a viable solution for taking down game. Even the legendary Fred Bear developed and held patents on drug-dispensing pods for hunting arrows. Bowhunters using liquid and powdered forms of powerful drugs such as anectine and succinylcholine chloride for deer hunting go back to the 1960s, and though they are illegal in many states, the science and ethics behind this practice continue to drum up debate. "Posion" loaded into "pods" at the tip of an arrow is meant to interact with the animal\'s muscle tissue and enter the blood stream, causing certain death from even a poorly placed shot. As of today, the Pope & Young Club, National Field Archery Association, American Archery Council and Professional Bowhunters Society are all opposed to pods and their use for hunting.



Recommended for You

Timing and presentation are key to a successful decoy strategy. Whitetail

How To Use Deer Decoys In The Rut

John Dudley

Timing and presentation are key to a successful decoy strategy.

Bill Winke says don't waste your time hunting these deer. Whitetail

Are Some Bucks Unkillable?

Bill Winke

Bill Winke says don't waste your time hunting these deer.

Mid-Summer Is Prime Time to Watch Large-Racked Bucks — and Stoke Fall Enthusiasm! How-To

Summer Scouting Spectacular

Bill Winke - July 17, 2019

Mid-Summer Is Prime Time to Watch Large-Racked Bucks — and Stoke Fall Enthusiasm!

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Bill Winke

Bill Winke's Bowhunting Treestand Set-Up Tips

Field Editor Bill Winke provides bowhunting treestand set-up tips that'll help make life easier when it's go time in the fall.

Springtime Turkey Hunt

Springtime Turkey Hunt

Kevin Steele and the boys are bowhunting turkeys with the help of some well-placed decoys.

See more Popular Videos

Trending Stories

Going from field tips to broadheads requires arrow tuning on a higher plane.

 Good broadhead flight How-To

4 Steps to Perfect Broadhead Flight

Bowhunting Online Staff

Going from field tips to broadheads requires arrow tuning on a higher plane. Good...

Check out our picks for the best new bow sights from the 2019 ATA Show! ATA Show

Best New Bow Sights for 2019

Tony J. Peterson - January 10, 2019

Check out our picks for the best new bow sights from the 2019 ATA Show!

Check out our top picks for the best new mechanical broadheads to debut at the 2019 ATA Show! ATA Show

New Mechanical Broadheads for 2019

Brian Strickland - January 10, 2019

Check out our top picks for the best new mechanical broadheads to debut at the 2019 ATA Show!

See More Stories

More Bow Accessories

Learn why many common concerns about single-pin sights are non-issues and how they can actually help your accuracy! Bow Accessories

Debunking Single-Pin Sight Myths

Jace Bauserman

Learn why many common concerns about single-pin sights are non-issues and how they can...

From full-containment to drop-away designs, we've covered the best arrow rests from the 2019 ATA Show! ATA Show

New Arrow Rests for 2019

Colton Bailey - January 11, 2019

From full-containment to drop-away designs, we've covered the best arrow rests from the 2019...

Boost comfort and reduce hand slip by adding a custom wrap to your bow's grip. Bow Accessories

Should You Wrap Your Bow Grip?

Jace Bauserman

Boost comfort and reduce hand slip by adding a custom wrap to your bow's grip.

See More Bow Accessories

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Temporary Price Reduction

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

×