Skip to main content

Is Moon-Related Movement A Myth?

There's an expression biologists use: "negative data are still data."

Essentially, it means that just because you don't get the results you expected, it doesn't mean you didn't learn something. For example, if we conduct the same experiment and get the same result, it wasn't necessarily a waste of time, because it confirms what we thought we knew to be true.


Wildlife biologists are forever trying to unlock the mysteries of whitetail deer. We're constantly pushing the envelope, but we also go back and check on conventional wisdom from time to time -- especially as new technology becomes available. For biologists and hunters alike (the two are not mutually exclusive), one area of great interest is factors influencing deer movement. Knowing what makes deer move could potentially give us an edge. And if we can predict deer movement, or at least when optimal conditions for deer movement will occur, then we also know when we should be in the woods.


Recently, at the 32nd annual meeting of the Southeast Deer Study Group, Stephen Webb presented a research paper on such an effort. He and co-authors Bronson Strickland, Kenneth Gee, Stephen Demarais and Randy DeYoung looked at what effects reproductive phase, moon phase and short-term weather patterns have on deer movements.

Similar research has been done numerous times before. However, previous research used radio collars, which may have provided one or two short observations per day. Webb's study used GPS tracking collars that transmitted deer locations every 15 minutes. Very few studies had ever documented movements on such a detailed level. One would expect the results to be much more accurate, though not necessarily different from what was previously found.


Lunar Lunacy
Bucks moved more during the rut. Nothing earth shattering there. It's what experience tells us and previous research has confirmed. Still, isn't it comforting to know it holds true, even under the scrutiny of the latest technological advancements? If bucks move more, they will be more susceptible to hunters. Now, if we could just hone that down a little to figure out when, during the rut, they might be more inclined to let their guard down.


Changes in weather (temperature, wind speed, pressure and relative humidity) had no statistically significant impact on deer movement during peak periods of dawn and dusk.

Weather-related variables only influenced movement during non-peak periods. In other words, the best time to be in the woods is early and late in the day. Again, pretty much what we knew. This one jibes with some, but not all previous studies. The differences are subtle, and hardly of the import of the third conclusion.

"Moon phase had no effect on daily, nocturnal and diurnal deer movements." I put that in quotes for a reason. I'm not paraphrasing or interpreting. That was as written in Webb's abstract. I guess it's just human nature, but we accept what we want to hear willingly, yet remain skeptical about the things we don't agree with. Webb's is the same result that keeps coming up in nearly all disciplined, scientific studies. Yet many deer hunters still refuse to accept it. Why?

Some if it may be wishful thinking. We so want the opposite to be true. And some may be due to what we observe -- or think we're observing -- without any real scientific control. Much, however, is the result of misinformation. Every so often, some pseudo-scientist comes along with a theory based on "results" from a non-scientific experiment (often largely anecdotal observation). They may have the best of intentions in trying to help their fellow hunters, though they're not. And because we hunters are so eager for answers, we're quick to accept the latest and greatest whitetail wisdom.

Meanwhile, biologists plod steadily along. Setting out to prove something we already know may seem a little frivolous at first. But wildlife biology is not an exact science. In fact, it's not a true science at all: it's a discipline. The inherent imperfections cry out for us to go back and take a second look, especially when we have new tools to do so. It's also important to bear in mind there are numerous uncontrollable variables, so results could differ significantly from one study area to the next.

To put it in bowhunting terms, whether you're shooting an old Bear Whitetail or a brand new Mathews Reezen, you would expect to make a 20-yard shot without much difficulty.

But I'll bet you're a whole lot more confident shooting the Mathews.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Ravin Broadheads – 3 New Mechanicals

Ravin Broadheads – 3 New Mechanicals

Designed exclusively for their crossbows, Ravin has announced three new mechanical broadheads to maximize penetration and overall performance.

Springtime Turkey Hunt

Springtime Turkey Hunt

Kevin Steele and the boys are bowhunting turkeys with the help of some well-placed decoys.

Center Shots: How to Improve Your Bow Tuning

Center Shots: How to Improve Your Bow Tuning

Field editor Bill Winke goes over steps you can take to improve the tuning on your bow.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

These boots are Field Tested: Danner Vital Snake Boots Apparel

Field Tested: Danner Vital Snake Boots

Taylor Pardue - July 13, 2020

These boots are "better safe than sorry" at its best.

A perfect shot requires a perfect release.Proper Archery Release Aid Technique How-To

Proper Archery Release Aid Technique

Larry Wise

A perfect shot requires a perfect release.

Following Bill Winke's step-by-step process for setting up and tuning a bow.Step-by-Step Bow Setup How-To

Step-by-Step Bow Setup

Bill Winke

Following Bill Winke's step-by-step process for setting up and tuning a bow.

The system offers ease of use, versatility, affordability and ever-expanding functionality.Moultrie Mobile: A Complete Scouting Solution Scouting Tools

Moultrie Mobile: A Complete Scouting Solution

Christian Berg - October 01, 2020

The system offers ease of use, versatility, affordability and ever-expanding functionality.

See More Trending Articles

More Whitetail

Prepare now to ensure a victorious whitetail season this fall.The Perfect Game Plan for Bowhunting Whitetails Whitetail

The Perfect Game Plan for Bowhunting Whitetails

Bill Winke

Prepare now to ensure a victorious whitetail season this fall.

This time of transition for whitetails may be the best month to utilize your grunt calls. October's Quiet Woods Can Be Broken Up by Timely Grunts Whitetail

October's Quiet Woods Can Be Broken Up by Timely Grunts

Lynn Burkhead

This time of transition for whitetails may be the best month to utilize your grunt calls.

Work now to see and kill more deer this fall.Fall Food-Plot Planting Guide Whitetail

Fall Food-Plot Planting Guide

Jason Snavely

Work now to see and kill more deer this fall.

These are the archery shots you should and shouldn't take on whitetails. Where to Shoot a Deer: Bowhunting Shot Placement How-To

Where to Shoot a Deer: Bowhunting Shot Placement

Christian Berg

These are the archery shots you should and shouldn't take on whitetails.

See More Whitetail

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE Arrow

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Petersen's Bowhunting App

Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Petersen's Bowhunting subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now