Head-to-Head Review: Best Trail Cameras of 2013

Head-to-Head Review: Best Trail Cameras of 2013

Few technologies have impacted our sport more than trail cameras. Take a minute to think of all the ways these tiny scouts work their way into your life as a bowhunter. I challenge you to turn on the Sportsman Channel and count the minutes it takes until you see or hear someone reference a trail camera; if you get past 30 minutes, it would be shocking.

Have you hunted with an outfitter in the past 10 years? They generally have photo albums full of trail-camera pictures and will often use the same in brochures, websites, Facebook pages, etc. Plus, there is no doubt your chances of success are greater if you are hunting with an outfitter who employs an army of trail cameras, because there is no better way to pattern game. Outfitters are also excellent sources to talk to about their choice in cameras and advice for using them effectively.

Of course, some people still argue that you should just put in the time and figure things out the old-fashioned way; and to an extent, I agree. Connecting with nature, understanding the lay of the land and being able to read deer sign helps greatly with camera placement. And the cameras will enhance your understanding as you start to see how the pieces of the puzzle fall into place. I encourage collaboration of old-school and new-school technologies; a little of Uncle Ted's "Mystical Flight of the Arrow" mixed with advanced circuitry, like the high-definition camera that filmed him in the hunt you watched on TV.

Game cameras also fit the lifestyle many of us lead today. We tend to be extremely busy with all the things that fill up a life — family, work, health, taking care of the house, shuttling kids all over creation and the list goes on. Game cameras are like little clones that allow you to be in the woods 24/7, keeping an eye on your hotspots regardless of other demands on your time. When you finally catch a break and head to the field, your time is maximized because you at least have some idea of what's going on thanks to your cameras. These benefits are amplified for individuals who hunt property far from home.


All of that brings us right back to the actual cameras. What is it that makes one camera better than another? It could be technology, quality or even application. If you have land in another state you only get to once or twice a year, then you would most likely put a premium on battery life as a starting point for camera selection.


If you were watching a lone trail in the middle of the woods where the animal is not likely to stop for anything, you may want a camera with fast trigger speed and recovery time, which would result in as many pictures as possible. Watching a food plot? Fast trigger speed may not be your focus; instead a slow trigger and an extended sensor range could be of prime interest. Or maybe you are on a budget and need significant adjustability so you can use the one camera in several applications/scenarios.


Whatever the case, the test results (see the gallery below) are meant to help you get further down the road in choosing the type and model camera that best suits your needs. We tested 13 of the year's top models, evaluating their performance in key areas using a head-to-head format. We performed the following six tests:

The Daylight Walkthough Test was performed by passing a subject in front of the cameras at seven specific distances (15, 25, 35, 45, 55, 65 and 75 feet) and at two known speeds. A consistent, measurable speed was achieved using our Bucky Pace Car System, which consists of a rigged-up Renzo decoy, a rope that was stretched across a small field and a drill motor regulated by a DC power supply and volt meter. The drill motor is attached to a line that pulls Bucky along the rope on a set of pulleys. By controlling the volts, we were able to control the speed, which we set up for two scenarios — a subject walking casually (1.94 fps) and one on a mission (5.94 fps).

Since trail cameras require both heat and motion to trigger their sensors, we had Chad Smith walk alongside Bucky. During the test, each camera had 14 opportunities to capture images (7 distances and two runs — one fast and one slow).


Field of view (FOV) was calculated through two known values — the 25-foot distance to the camera and the 10-foot markers in the picture (our scale). A Staedtler Mars 12-inch triangular engineer's scale was used to measure the width of the actual picture and the on-screen width of the 10-foot markers. The picture width was adjusted to scale for the FOV.

Detection angle was also measured at 25 feet and was calculated by using the engineer's scale to measure the distance from the subject to the edge of the picture. This was subtracted from the distance between the picture's mid-point to the edge. The distance the subject traveled after the trigger until the picture was taken was calculated using our known speed and the unit's tested trigger speed.

The relationship between a camera's lens FOV and infrared detection angle significantly impacts its performance. Cameras with a detection angle significantly narrower than the lens' FOV tend to capture images with the subject relatively close to the center of the frame.


However, such units also may not detect animals that move in and out of the periphery of the camera's FOV. Conversely, cameras with detection angles that are wider than the lens' FOV don't center subjects as well and may result in multiple "blank" pictures with no animals. But the upside is that the wide detection angle makes it less likely that an animal will pass within range without triggering the camera.

The Results

The first picture each camera captured was at the slow speed and at a distance of 25 feet. In the case of the Covert, we used the 35-foot slow picture because the subject was out of frame at 25 feet. That gives an overall feel for the quality of the pictures and the field of view.

All 13 cameras in the Daylight Walkthrough Test were capable of detecting motion out to at least 45 feet. When we moved back to 55 feet, the cameras from Primos, Simmons, Stealth Cam and Wildview dropped out. When we moved back to 65 feet, Browning, Moultrie and Wildgame dropped out. And when we moved back to 75 feet, Reconyx dropped out. That left five of the 13 cameras — Bushnell Trophy Cam HD Max, Covert Extreme Black 60, Eyecon Storm, Minox DTC 600 and SpyPoint BF-6 — that successfully detected motion at our maximum test range of 75 feet.

This test also gave us the total number of pictures each camera captured during the 14 passes (seven distances, two speeds). The four with the most pictures were: Bushnell Trophy Cam HD Max (50), Reconyx HC600 (50), Moultrie M-880 (18) and Minox DTC 600 (17). Although the ability to capture more pictures does not necessarily make a camera better, such models may be ideal for use along game trails where subjects are quickly entering and exiting the camera's FOV.

Flash Effectiveness Test

Our Flash Effectiveness Test measured the distance each camera's flash is able to effectively illuminate a subject for nighttime photos. We set up the cameras one at a time on a moonless night with a series of 3-D targets laid out in front of them and activated each camera two times. We had a stegosaurus at 15 feet, gobbler at 25, bedded ram at 35, fallow deer at 45, antelope at 55, wolf at 65 and mule deer at 75.

Trigger Speed Test

Once again this year, our trigger speed testing was conducted by the experts at TrailCamPro.com, who generously volunteered their time, knowledge and use of their Triggernator machine. TrailCamPro's technical wizard, Charles, invented the Triggernator and describes it this way:

"The Triggernator," nicknamed by the staff at TrailCamPro, is a device to accurately measure the trigger time of scouting cameras. Trigger time is the time differential between a target being detected and a picture taken. To accurately measure this time, the Triggernator passes a heated target by the center of the PIR detector of the test camera and at the same time starts a stopwatch displayed on a computer monitor. The test camera will take a picture of the running stopwatch and give us the trigger time. We run the test many times looking for consistency and then average the test results to obtain the average trigger time of that particular game camera."

Recovery Time Test

Like the Trigger Speed Test, the Recovery Time Test was conducted by the experts at TrailCamPro.com. Recovery time measures how quickly a camera can store the first picture and be ready to capture a second picture.

Nighttime Blur Test

Our Nighttime Blur Test was set up in the same way as our Daylight Walkthrough Test, except it was done at night and each camera was tested individually rather than in a group. This was done to prevent infrared flash interference from camera to camera. Once a camera was set, the motorized retrieval system was used to bring the subject past the lens on the slow speed setting (1.94 fps) at a distance of 25 feet. This was a one-pass test, with only one picture from each camera used for data.

Why do this test? Well, if you have been using trail cameras for a while then you know how frustrating it is to get a picture of what may be a huge animal but the blur keeps you from deciphering any detail.

Nighttime Trigger Range Test

The Nighttime Trigger Range Test measured the maximum distance at which a camera will trigger on a rapidly moving subject — at night. This was accomplished by someone walking briskly in front of the camera in 10-foot increments until the camera was no longer triggered. Once the distance was outside a camera's range, we moved back toward the camera in one-foot increments until motion was detected.

You may ask why we conducted this test at night. The answer is simple; the red infrared flash LEDs on the cameras would light up, letting us know the camera had detected movement. Models with black LEDs were very hard or impossible to detect. For those cameras, we had to remove the data cards and inspect the pictures, if there were any, to determine if there was detection at that range.

Browning Spec Ops

Browning\'s Spec Ops trail camera blends stealth and power in an affordable package. With an 8 megapixel resolution and advertised battery life of up to 10,000 images, the camera is designed for the most demanding of hunters. The camera is capable of recording video in HD, capturing time lapses, and live playback while in the field.

Results:

Field of view: 43.77 degrees
Detection Angle: 51.95 degrees
Trigger to Picture: 1.36 ft
Detection from Center of Image: 12.18 ft
Trigger Speed: .700 sec
Recovery Time: 2.3 sec
Nighttime Range: 44 ft
Battery Type and Life: 8 AA, up to 10,000 images

Bushnell Trophy Cam HD Max

The Bushnell Trophy Cam HD Max is the perfect blend of power and versatility. Featuring 8 megapixel resolution, advertised trigger speed of 0.6 seconds, minimum delay of 1 second, time lapse capabilities, and HD video the Trophy Cam HD Max is rightfully touted by Bushnell as being the ultimate trail camera.

Price: $249.99

Results:

Field of view: 44.61 degrees
Detection Angle: 45.20 degrees
Trigger to Picture: 1.45 ft
Detection from Center of Image: 10.41 ft
Trigger Speed: .747 sec
Recovery Time: 2.9 sec
Nighttime Range: 59 ft
Battery Type and Life: 4-12 AA, up to 1 year

Covert Extreme Black 60

Covert\'s powerful Extreme Black 60 is an excellent choice for those seeking a trail camera with loads of memory and security capabilities. With a 12 megapixel resolution, 1.2 second advertised trigger speed, invisible LED flash, 1 year advertised battery life, 32GB SD memory, and the addition of HD video and sound the Extreme Black 60 is designed to perform and last.

Price: $229.99

Results:

Field of view: 42.73 degrees
Detection Angle: 58.66 degrees
Trigger to Picture: 1.52 ft
Detection from Center of Image: 19.67 ft
Trigger Speed: .787 sec
Recovery Time: 9.5 sec
Nighttime Range: 55 ft
Battery Type and Life: 12 AA, up to 1 year

Eyecon Storm

The Eyecon Storm is designed for performance in the field. Featuring a backlit LED screen with its 9 megapixel resolution, 0.33 second advertised trigger speed, SD video, and an advertised battery life up to 40,000 images the Storm is a serious trail camera for serious hunters.

Price: $229.99

Results:

Field of view: 44.14 degrees
Detection Angle: 15.25 degrees
Trigger to Picture: 1.26 ft
Detection from Center of Image: 3.35 ft
Trigger Speed: .650 sec
Recovery Time: 11.7 sec
Nighttime Range: 51 ft
Battery Type and Life: 6 C, up to 40,000 images

Minox DTC 600

The Minox DTC 600 is a small, compact, and reliable trail camera with powerful capabilities. Touting 8 megapixel resolution, IR flash filters, less than 1 second trigger speed, and advertised battery life of up to six months make this trail camera perfect for hunting grounds and game parks alike.

Price: $279.00

Results:

Field of view: 44.53 degrees
Detection Angle: 18.36 degrees
Trigger to Picture: 3.18 ft
Detection from Center of Image: 4.04 ft
Trigger Speed: 1.643 sec
Recovery Time: 9.2 sec
Nighttime Range: 75 ft
Battery Type and Life: 10 AA, up to 6 months

Moultrie M-880

The Moultrie M-880 improves upon the M-80XT with its 8 megapixel camera, improved trigger speeds of less than 1 second, and the addition of HD video capabilities. Boasting a battery life of up to 9,500 images and four modes of use the M-880 is the perfect camera for hunters on a budget.

Price: $159.99

Results:

Field of view: 43.72 degrees
Detection Angle: 49.66 degrees
Trigger to Picture: 1.68 ft
Detection from Center of Image: 11.57 ft
Trigger Speed: .869 sec
Recovery Time: 2.3 sec
Nighttime Range: 49 ft
Battery Type and Life: 8 AA, up to 9,500 images

Primos Ultra 46

Hunters seeking affordability without sacrificing performance should check out Primos\' Ultra 46. With its 7 megapixel resolution, 1 second advertised trigger speed, and choice between video, photo, or time lapse photos the Ultra 46 is great for the hunter on a budget.

Price: $159.99

Results:

Field of view: 35.99 degrees
Detection Angle: 46.62 degrees
Trigger to Picture: 1.83 ft
Detection from Center of Image: 10.77 ft
Trigger Speed: .869 sec
Recovery Time: 7.3 sec
Nighttime Range: 45 ft
Battery Type and Life: 8 AA, up to 9 months

Reconyx HC600

The Reconyx HC600 is a performance powerhouse. With the 3.1 megapixel resolution, 0.2 second advertised trigger speed and minimum delay, and battery life of up to one year the HC600 boasts enhanced image quality for both day and night photos.

Price: $549.99

Results:

Field of view: 44.92 degrees
Detection Angle: 39.66 degrees
Trigger to Picture: .46 ft
Detection from Center of Image: 9.02 ft
Trigger Speed: .237 sec
Recovery Time: .9 sec
Nighttime Range: 57 ft
Battery Type and Life: 12 AA, up to 1 year

Simmons Whitetail

If dependability and value in a trail camera are important to you then the Simmons Whitetail fits the bill. With 6 megapixel resolution, 1 second advertised trigger speed, and a battery life of up to 6 months the Simmons Whitetail is a great value for hunters on a budget.

Price: $99.99

Results:

Field of view: 44.61 degrees
Detection Angle: 41.32 degrees
Trigger to Picture: 2.51 ft
Detection from Center of Image: 9.43 ft
Trigger Speed: 1.294
Recovery Time: 8.9 sec
Nighttime Range: 46 ft
Battery Type and Life: 4 AA, up to 6 months

Spypoint BF-6

The Spypoint BF-6 trail camera features 6 megapixel resolution, 0.8 second advertised trigger speed, and up to one year of battery life. Black LEDs help keep this camera invisible during the night while the removable internal camera make this one of the easiest trail cameras to use.

Price: $149.99

Results:

Field of view: 40.05 degrees
Detection Angle: 48.57 degrees
Trigger to Picture: 3.42 ft
Detection from Center of Image: 11.28 ft
Trigger Speed: 1.768 sec
Recovery Time: 9.9 sec
Nighttime Range: 55 ft
Battery Type and Life: 6 AA, up to 1 year

Stealth Cam Unit X Ops

The Stealth Cam Unit X Ops trail camera boasts impressive features at an attractable price. Featuring 8 megapixel resolution, 0.7 second advertised trigger speed, 5 second minimum delay, time lapse photos and HD video capabilities the Unit X meets the needs of any hunter.

Price: $169.99

Results:

Field of view: 44.45 degrees
Detection Angle: 39.26 degrees
Trigger to Picture: 1.63 ft
Detection from Center of Image: 8.92 ft
Trigger Speed: .843 sec
Recovery Time: 10 sec
Nighttime Range: 45 ft
Battery Type and Life: 8 AA, not listed

Wildgame Innovations Razor 6 Lightsout

The Wildgame Innovations Razor 6 Lightsout trail camera features 6 megapixel resolution, 1 second advertised trigger speed, battery life up to 30,000 images, and HD video capabilities. With a flash range of up to 50 feet and Exposure Control System for clearer images, the Razor 6 is attractively affordable and highly versatile.

Price: $139.99

Results:

Field of view: 38.44 degrees
Detection Angle: 10.01 degrees
Trigger to Picture: 1.47 ft
Detection from Center of Image: 2.19 ft
Trigger Speed: .760 sec
Recovery Time: 14.3 sec
Nighttime Range: 47 ft
Battery Type and Life: 8 AA, up to 30,000 images

Wildview TK30

Those hunting for a basic, no frills attached trail camera should check out the Wildview TK30. With 8 megapixel resolution, 0.75 advertised trigger speed, and HD video capabilities the TK30 gets the job done.

Price: $119.99

Results:

Field of view: 44.61 degrees
Detection Angle: 47.54 degrees
Trigger to Picture: .76 ft
Detection from Center of Image: 11.01 ft
Trigger Speed: .393 sec
Recovery Time: 23.2 sec
Nighttime Range: 47 ft
Battery Type and Life: 8 AA, not listed

Recommended for You

A new generation of highly mobile bowhunters is embracing the lightweight comfort and versatility of tree saddles. Here's everything you need to know to get started in tree saddle hunting. How-To

BOWHUNTING's Guide to Tree Saddle Hunting

Greg Staggs - May 15, 2019

A new generation of highly mobile bowhunters is embracing the lightweight comfort and...

Mid-Summer Is Prime Time to Watch Large-Racked Bucks — and Stoke Fall Enthusiasm! How-To

Summer Scouting Spectacular

Bill Winke - July 17, 2019

Mid-Summer Is Prime Time to Watch Large-Racked Bucks — and Stoke Fall Enthusiasm!

Treestand hunting is not an exact science. We all learn with experience, and there is definitely an Whitetail

10 Best Treestand Hunting Tips

Bill Winke

Treestand hunting is not an exact science. We all learn with experience, and there is...

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Crossbow Boar Hunting

Crossbow Boar Hunting

Craig Boddington is armed with his crossbow and puts the stalk on a wild boar.

First Look: Mathews Vertix Bow

First Look: Mathews Vertix Bow

"Petersen's Bowhunting" editor Christian Berg and Mathews design engineer Mark Hayes talk the smooth, quiet and fast shooting qualities of the new flagship Vertix bow from the Wisconsin bowmaker.

Springtime Turkey Hunt

Springtime Turkey Hunt

Kevin Steele and the boys are bowhunting turkeys with the help of some well-placed decoys.

See more Popular Videos

Trending Stories

We've rounded up the best new compound bows at the 2019 ATA Show. Here are our top picks for the year! ATA Show

Best New Bows for 2019

Tony J. Peterson - January 10, 2019

We've rounded up the best new compound bows at the 2019 ATA Show. Here are our top picks for...

We Rank 16 Top Models on Sharpness, Accuracy, Penetration & More


It's that time of year when Arrows & Broadheads

2017 Fixed-Blade Broadhead Test

Jon E. Silks - December 12, 2017

We Rank 16 Top Models on Sharpness, Accuracy, Penetration & More It's that time of year...

Check out our list of the best new hunting arrows from the 2019 ATA Show! ATA Show

Top New Arrows for 2019

Tony J. Peterson - January 10, 2019

Check out our list of the best new hunting arrows from the 2019 ATA Show!

See More Stories

More Bow Accessories

See how this compact, lightweight bowsight stacked up in our field test Bow Accessories

Field Tested: Black Gold Ascent Whitetail Bowsight

Taylor Pardue - May 10, 2019

See how this compact, lightweight bowsight stacked up in our field test

This lightweight bowsight offers bowhunters the best of both worlds Bow Accessories

Field Tested: IQ Pro Hunter

Taylor Pardue - August 30, 2019

This lightweight bowsight offers bowhunters the best of both worlds

Boost comfort and reduce hand slip by adding a custom wrap to your bow's grip. Bow Accessories

Should You Wrap Your Bow Grip?

Jace Bauserman

Boost comfort and reduce hand slip by adding a custom wrap to your bow's grip.

See More Bow Accessories

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Temporary Price Reduction

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.