Where to Kill a Big Buck This Year

Some whitetail hunters set an antler size standard at the start of each bow season. I'm a huge believer in setting goals. I also believe strongly that satisfaction is a function of expectations. Simply stated, if you set your goal to harvest a 125-inch buck and you harvest a 140-inch buck, you will probably be very pleased with your hunting season. If you harvest a buck with 125-class antlers, you will probably be pleased with your season. And if you harvest a buck that scores 80, you may feel you didn't accomplish your mission.

I hunt for enjoyment and as a way to provide my family natural, lean, healthy meat! I'm not ashamed to admit I've tagged way more does in my life than bucks. I enjoyed every roast and loin! Still, I'd be lying if I said I didn't hope to tag a "nice" buck each year.


Grow Up!


As a biologist, I've learned harvesting a buck of a certain antler size is not simply based on the amount of time spent hunting or the skills a hunter possesses. There are known factors that impact the average antler size of bucks in any area. The biggest factor is usually the buck's age.


If growing conditions are normal (no disease, severe droughts, etc.), bucks will usually produce larger antlers each year of their life until they are 5 years old or older. Physical maturity for whitetails occurs around 5 to 7 years of age, depending on the amount of stress bucks experience throughout their lives. Stress can be related to food quality, adult sex ratio, predation, etc. The level of stress is usually fairly constant for all deer living in an area.


Years ago, Dr. Harry Jacobson, a professor at Mississippi State University, conducted research that showed bucks expressed 25 percent of their antler potential at 1'‰½, 62 percent at 2'‰½, 77 percent at 3'‰½, 91 percent at 4'‰½ and 100 percent at 5'‰½. Very similar findings were reported by Dr. Mickey Hellickson from South Texas.

Management Works Everywhere


Clearly, one of the best ways to harvest a buck with large antlers is to hunt where folks opt to pass younger bucks. This can be a farm, lease or area with cooperating neighbors who decide not to kill bucks until they reach a certain age class.

States such as Kentucky and Kansas employ another proven strategy statewide. They allow hunters only one buck per season, no matter the choice of weapon or size of the buck. By limiting the number of bucks harvested, more bucks will likely reach older age classes. The percentage of hunters who harvest large-antlered, mature deer in those states each year is proof the strategy is working!

Another example is my farm near Branson in southern Missouri. My land is split by a county line. The last I checked, there had never been a Pope and Young or Boone and Crockett entry from either county. The countryside is primarily covered with low-quality oak/hickory timber and fescue pasture. Both provide low-quality food and cover for whitetails, and the local hunting tradition is not to pass up any buck.

Some folks argue that the reason very few large-antlered bucks are killed in these counties is genetics. However, most of the deer that were used to restock (the genetic source) northern Missouri decades ago were from the Ozark Mountains. The world record non-typical buck was found dead in northern Missouri, and the area produces a steady stream of Pope and Young and Boone and Crockett entries. The difference between the size of bucks harvested in northern and southern Missouri is the bucks in northern Missouri have access to much better groceries (corn and soybean fields). Further, hunters in northern Missouri readily recognize the potential of bucks if allowed to mature, so yearling bucks comprise a smaller percentage of the annual buck harvest.

I work with a group of families in south Florida that have a relatively large, long-term lease of a cattle ranch. Because of the cattle operation and the fact that about half of the club will flood annually due to the monsoon cycle, there are no or very few food plots each year. Yet, they continually harvest bucks with a bow that score in the 130s to 150s — in south Florida! How many guys travel to the Midwest or Canada and don't tag a buck of that quality?

The point is that deer management can work anywhere. If bucks are allowed to mature, they will produce larger antlers. This form of deer management is not for everyone. I understand and support that. However, those hunters who want to harvest large-antlered bucks need to either hunt where a majority of bucks are allowed to reach maturity or hope to find the proverbial needle in a haystack by tagging one of the rare bucks that survived to maturity in a lesser area.

Next month, I'll discuss research about nutrition's role in determining antler size.

Ben Brogle

Hunter: Ben Brogle
Location: Garrard, Ky.
Gross Score: 267 4/8
Net Score: 260 1/8 P&Y
Method: Bow

Brian S. Damery

Hunter: Brian S. Damery
Location: Macon, Ill.
Gross Score: 231 1/8
Net Score: 200 2/8 B&C
Method: Gun

Bruce Ewan

Hunter: Bruce Ewan
Location: Saskatchewan
Gross Score: 219 4/8
Net Score: 202 6/8 B&C
Method: Gun

Cliff Pickell

Hunter: Cliff Pickell
Location: Greenwood, Kan.
Gross Score: 259 5/8
Net Score: 249 6/8 P&Y
Method: Bow

Craig Calerone

Hunter: Craig Calderone
Location: Jackson, Miss.
Gross Score: 206 3/8
Net Score: 193 2/8 B&C
Method: Bow

Curt van Lith

Hunter: Curt van Lith
Location: Wright, Minn.
Gross Score: 217 7/8
Net Score: 197 6/8 P&Y
Method: Bow

David Grundy

Hunter: David Grundy
Location: Lapurte, Ind.
Gross Score: 240 4/8
Net Score: 225 6/8 B&C
Method: Gun

David L. Klemm

Hunter: David L. Klemm
Location: Mahoning, Ohio
Gross Score: 255 5/8
Net Score: 243 3/8 B&C
Method: Gun

David Manderscheid

Hunter: David Manderscheid
Location: Jackson, Iowa
Gross Score: 265 7/8
Net Score: 256 7/8 B&C
Method: Gun

Douglas A. Siebert

Hunter: Douglas A. Siebert
Location: Chase, Kan.
Gross Score: 251 2/8
Net Score: 245 4/8
Method: Bow

Duane Linscott

Hunter: Duane Linscott
Location: Unknown
Gross Score: 266 7/8
Net Score: 259 5/8 B&C
Method: Gun

George Chalus

Hunter: George Chalus
Location: Hudson Bay, Saskatchewan, Canada
Gross Score: 200 1/8
Net Score: 191 6/8
Method: Gun

Henry Mitchell

Hunter: Henry Mitchell
Location: Switzerland, Ind.
Gross Score: 242 4/8
Net Score: 233 2/8
Method: Gun

Howard Pauls

Hunter: Howard G. Pauls
Location: Souris, Manitoba, Canada
Gross Score: 270 1/8
Net Score: 265 7/8 B&C
Method: Muzzleloader

Jamie Remmers

Hunter: Jamie Remmers
Location: Marion, Kan.
Gross Score: 272 5/8
Net Score: 257 1/8 B&C
Method: Gun

John A. Breen

Hunter: John A. Breen
Location: Funkley, Minn.
Gross Score: 215 0/8
Net Score: 202 0/8 B&C
Method: Gun

Kenneth Barcus

Hunter: Kenneth Barcus
Location: Nodayay, Mo.
Gross Score: 239 7/8
Net Score: 222 5/8 B&C
Method: Gun

Kenneth R. Cartwright

Hunter: Kenneth R. Cartwright
Location: Miami, Kan.
Gross Score: 255 3/8
Net Score: 250 6/8
Method: Bow

Kenneth B. Fowler

Hunter: Kenneth B. Fowler
Location: Reno, Kan.
Gross Score: 273 1/8
Net Score: 257 0/8
Method: Bow

Kent Petry

Hunter: Kent Petry
Location: Flathead, Mon.
Gross Score: 203 6/8
Net Score: 199 2/8 B&C
Method: Gun

Kevin Peterson

Hunter: Kevin Peterson
Location: Des Moines, Iowa
Gross Score: 209 7/8
Net Score: 188 1/8 P&Y
Method: Bow

Kevin Wright

Hunter: Kevin Wright
Location: Meade, Kan.
Gross Score: 245 2/8
Net Score: 238 0/8 P&Y
Method: Bow

Lamonte Stark

Hunter: Lamonte Stark
Location: Henry, Iowa
Gross Score: 203 5/8
Net Score: 189 3/8 B&C
Method: Gun

Larry Raveling

Hunter: Larry Raveline
Location: Iowa
Gross Score: 288 5/8
Net Score: 282 B&C
Method: Gun

Lloyd Goade

Hunter: Lloyd Goade
Location: Monroe, Iowa Gross Score: Unknown
Net Score: 197 6/8 P&Y
Method: Bow

M.J. Johnson

Hunter: M.J. Johnson
Location: Peoria, Ill.
Gross Score: 211 6/8
Net Score: 204 4/8 P&Y
Method:Bow

Michael J. Okray

Hunter: Michael J. Okray
Location: Cheyenne, Colo.
Gross Score: 268 2/8
Net Score: 258 2/8 B&C
Method: Bow

Robert Chestnut

Hunter: Robert Chestnut
Location: Vermillion, Ill.
Gross Score: 258 3/8
Net Score: 245 5/8 P&Y
Method: Bow

Ronald K. Osbourne

Hunter: Ronald K. Osbourne
Location: Mahoning, Ohio
Gross Score: 243 1/8
Net Score: 238 6/8 P&Y
Method: Bow

Sam G. Townsend

Hunter: Sam G. Townsend
Location: Iroquois, Ill.
Gross Score: 239 4/8
Net Score: 231 4/8 P&Y
Method:Bow

Tim Goode

Hunter: Tim Goode
Location: Indiana
Gross Score: 261 0/8
Net Score: 215 4/8 B&C
Method: Gun

Tony Lovstuen

Hunter: Tony Lovstuen
Location: Albia, Iowa
Gross Score: 324 0/8
Net Score: 307 5/8 B&C
Method: Muzzleloader

Recommended for You

Follow Bill Winke's tips to ensure you have the most accurate bowhunting setup possible. How-To

Goof-Proof Tips For Sighting-In Your Bow

Bill Winke

Follow Bill Winke's tips to ensure you have the most accurate bowhunting setup possible.




Related Stories> Ted Nugent Talks About His New Book> Mule Deep In The Backcountry> Podcasts

Still Going Strong

October 28, 2010

Related Stories> Ted Nugent Talks About His New Book> Mule Deep In The Backcountry>

We tested this new trail-cam technology! Scouting Tools

Moultrie Mobile Cellular Camera: Remote Scouting Made Simple

Christian Berg - July 22, 2019

We tested this new trail-cam technology!

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Center Shots: How to Improve Your Bow Tuning

Center Shots: How to Improve Your Bow Tuning

Field editor Bill Winke goes over steps you can take to improve the tuning on your bow.

Crossbow Boar Hunting

Crossbow Boar Hunting

Craig Boddington is armed with his crossbow and puts the stalk on a wild boar.

First Look: Mathews Vertix Bow

First Look: Mathews Vertix Bow

"Petersen's Bowhunting" editor Christian Berg and Mathews design engineer Mark Hayes talk the smooth, quiet and fast shooting qualities of the new flagship Vertix bow from the Wisconsin bowmaker.

See more Popular Videos

Trending Stories

We've rounded up the best new compound bows at the 2019 ATA Show. Here are our top picks for the year! ATA Show

Best New Bows for 2019

Tony J. Peterson - January 10, 2019

We've rounded up the best new compound bows at the 2019 ATA Show. Here are our top picks for...

Check out our list of the best new hunting arrows from the 2019 ATA Show! ATA Show

Top New Arrows for 2019

Tony J. Peterson - January 10, 2019

Check out our list of the best new hunting arrows from the 2019 ATA Show!

We Rank 16 Top Models on Sharpness, Accuracy, Penetration & More


It's that time of year when Arrows & Broadheads

2017 Fixed-Blade Broadhead Test

Jon E. Silks - December 12, 2017

We Rank 16 Top Models on Sharpness, Accuracy, Penetration & More It's that time of year...

See More Stories

More Whitetail

The general timing of the rut is controlled by photoperiod (the number of daylight hours) but the exact timing of breeding can be influenced by a variety of factors. Whitetail

A Deer Biologist's Dissection of The Rut

Jason Snavely

The general timing of the rut is controlled by photoperiod (the number of daylight hours) but...

Last year marked the first time I shared my rut predictions with the readers of Petersen's Whitetail

The Best Days to Tag Trophy Bucks in 2016

John Dudley - October 19, 2016

Last year marked the first time I shared my rut predictions with the readers of Petersen's



Hunting deer is far from predictable. It is not like baking a pie or programming a computer, Whitetail

How to Shoot Your Biggest Buck Ever

Bill Winke - November 02, 2016

Hunting deer is far from predictable. It is not like baking a pie or programming a computer,

See More Whitetail

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Temporary Price Reduction

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

×